Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alan Schmidt's avatar

The issue with the people who want to dispel the monarchy is thy actually don't believe in popular sovereignty either, even if some are naive enough to think such a thing is possible. Their ideal world is un-rooted technocrats putting edicts on people they have no relation or care about solely based on "The Science" and "Equality". They see people as Human Undifferentiated Matter in which no one should have any unique, immutable properties that might hinder the march of progress.

In the end, they are monsters just as evil as Pol Pot.

Expand full comment
Ed wood's avatar

I never thought I'd say it but I think you're being too optimistic. The reaction of a lot of the new elite to the lovely weekend was thinly veiled disgust and embarrassment and I don't see a way that the monarchy survives in the world 30 years from now when that elite has burrowed ever deeper into control of every aspect of government and culture. You can do the Peter Hitchens Churchill/Diana funeral comparison with royal events and with each one it becomes less august, less serious, tweer with more sops thrown to those who will never be satisfied. It certainly is more resilient than any other conservative institution but I can't see monarchism doing anything other than dropping in status

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts