Years ago, I remember reading this evocative article about the hugely charismatic Egyptian leader Gamal Abdel Nasser, wondering what might have happened had Nasser followed the Lee Kuan Yew path instead of pursuing his revolutionary and socialist policies!
The face of the Middle East might have been, at least partly, very different. Egypt had the potential, the institutions, and the history—but so much of that potential was squandered!
Unfortunately, there does not seem to be the ability to understand the contribution of Western civilization in Arab countries (perhaps one can somewhat understand their prejudice) where Sinapore, Taiwan, Korea and even Japan have been able to do so, with much greater success, prosperity and maybe even happiness for those nations' people than much of the post-colonial world.
Egypt should be an economic powerhouse: it is, and appears always to have been, a basket case. And that has nothing to do with colonialism, where Lord Cromer's (and others) decades long interest in modernization of Egyptian administration, industry and agriculture was buried in the sands like the Sphinx.
I visited Singapore in 1984 as a young naval officer. Already then it was very clean and orderly, unlike other Asisan cities I had visited. Crime was essentially non-existent and we were told that this was not the place to get too rowdy or get in trouble because it wasn't tolerated. You can get an idea of how safe a city is by noticing groups of school girls walking alone after dark. The food was fabulous and relatively cheap due to the strong dollar in those days. I have always thought of Singapore fondly and glad for their success.
Hong Kong, when I was there (1994-2001, 2008-2011) was similar, though its inevitable Sinicization after 1997 (with tragic results since 2019) has made it a different and worse city - for all.
Coincidentally, I read this immediately after reading a review of the documentary movie “Empire of Dust” (the source of the “it’s all so tiresome” meme), in which the reviewer reflects that the Congo (et al.) took almost entirely the opposite approach to the great Singaporean.
Of course the Congolese were in a difficult situation, but still…
The break up of the Federation of Malay States is also my favourite response to that old dimwitted Scottish nationalist argument "Which country has not wanted to become independent?"
That the easy answer became such a success against its will, against the odds and with a firm grasp of economic reality adds to the humour.
Against its will? Perhaps against its best laid plans but I don’t think LKY or any of the leaders of the Singaporean faction wanted to be a unified part of the Federation of Malaya as constituted in 1965.
They negotiated fulsome and specific legal safeguards for near complete legal autonomy before they ventured to join in 1963. They had been a separate Crown Colony up to that point and never previously a part of the Malayan Federation or the Union or States that had preceded it.
Then they set about trying to undermine the privileged constitutional status and customary position of the Malays. Only then were they ejected.
In many ways it was a failed ‘hostile take over’ by an annexed exclave rather than an expulsion of a constituent state.
There is a lot of fine detail that gets missed when people set about allegorising the Singaporean miracle.
"Then they set about trying to undermine the privileged constitutional status and customary position of the Malays. Only then were they ejected." Any why wouldn't they? Bumiputra policy was racial preference in naked form.
Everyone in that part of the world thinks in what we would call ‘racial’ terms. Britain explicitly did until decolonisation. And then more or less implicitly thereafter. Until the last 15 years or so.
Malays consider themselves the indigenous people of the Malay peninsula and therefore feel entitled to the stewardship of the land and its resources.
How so? It strikes me that they have, for the most part, maintained their traditional and customary way of life with a state that is modernising and developing well on the terms they have laid down to best suit their own people.
They have had the best of globalism without many of the drawbacks.
"Lee would have gone on to great things in any case, but he happened to come of age in a notably turbulent period. If worldviews are indeed shaped by the events of an individual’s twentieth year, for the budding young law student it was the fall of Singapore in February 1942, the British Empire’s greatest defeat and humiliation. Lee noted at the time that, whatever happened next, this was the end of European rule."
I believe it was Napoleon Bonaparte who stated that if you want to understand a man, look at what was happening in the world when he was twenty.
The fall of not just Singapore but the whole of Malaya as it then was in 1941-42 is fascinating. The surprise attack began slightly before Pearl Harbour - yes, you read that right - but because of the International Date Line, history usually claims otherwise. The Vichy French helped the Japanese, as did the Thais (a bit), and the Japanese modelled their tactics on the German Blitzkrieg successes of 1940 in France. The British (Empire) could have kept them at bay, but their top leadership was so inept that it became, as Ed says, arguably one of the worst defeats in British military history.
My Malay sister in laws father saw the British soldiers retreating over the river Muar and blowing up the last bridges - ‘knock-kneed and coughing like hags’
He said he’d never seen a White Man unshaven before in his life.
Like LKY in the above piece, he said that, more even than the fall of Singapore itself, made him realise the Empire was over.
The Malaya garrison was absolutely tiny up to that point. It’s amazing how much of the Empire in the East Indies was effectively run in bluster and goodwill.
I can believe it. My Chinese-Singaporean friend says her father was in Singapore during the occupation and not surprisingly absolutely hated the Japanese from that point on!
The military debacle essentially rested on a completely daft premise IMO: the British Empire troops, many of them Indian, would invade southern Thailand when they were sure the Japanese were about to land there themselves, but they needed ideally about three days notice to get into position - which the Japanese didn’t give them, the bounders! There is also the naval aspect, with two RN battleships sunk from the air with minimal losses on the Japanese side…
"Yet the end of empire is always a precarious times for minorities, especially merchant peoples, and a majority Chinese city surrounded by majority Malay regions found itself very vulnerable, both from outside and within. As he put it: ‘We inherited the island without its hinterland, a heart without a body.’"
Hence the need for a "liberal case for empire" as you would say:
"The great-grandson of Hakka-speaking immigrants, Lee came from the somewhat Anglicised Straits Chinese elite. Often British in their mindset, Lee describes himself as ‘the last Victorian’ and this worldview would shape Singapore’s history. "
One wonders if Prime Minister Ian Smith of Rhodesia might dispute that title.
1. Can a British Lee Kuan Yew rise from the ashes?
2. Can he confront the nation with hard truths?
3. Can he deal firmly but objectively with the prevailing narratives of the last five decades?
4. Can he tell the new hard right that British Muslims are not necessarily the enemy, while also telling British Muslims that necessary adjustments must be made?
5. Can he be a little patriarchal and tell white British women to end their addiction to OnlyFans and what have you?
6. Can he focus on excellent governance and motivate both the population and the chattering classes to move beyond the never-ending and futile ideological wars?
7. Can he speak to people honestly, but humanely, about the meaning of belonging and identity?
Two things I find depressing about British politics:
1. A (small) majority of voters are left-wing. The Conservative Party won elections in England the past because the left wing vote was split between two parties (Labour and the Liberal Democrats). But now the right-wing vote is split too. Also, younger people are more left-wing than older people. So I don't think the British public will ever take to anyone who confronts them with hard truths.
2. Both of our right-wing parties, the Conservatives and Reform, are ignoring the fact that Britain has huge debts and borrowing costs are high. They are both promising tax cuts and higher spending (for example, on defence), with no realistic plan to pay for the things they are promising. They are also both NIMBY parties who won't face up to the need to build things (houses, electricity pylons) on the green belt or in the bucolic countryside.
I hope so . . . Just as in 1979, there is a time for a great man, or great woman to save us from ourselves. But it is a matter of will and choice. Always.
A British Lee Kwan Yew’s first target would be the racial pride and historic exceptionalism of the indigenous people of Britain. That is the prologue to the Singapore story that is so poorly understood by his backers in Britain.
He would say to the English, as he said to the Malays in the ancient lands of their fathers - ‘you have no special right or place in this land over and above anyone else. Your history is abolished. Your title to normative culture in this place is revoked. Your expectation of special consideration in the disposal of its destiny is refused. Your claim to inherited oversight and stewardship of this land is forthwith denied.’
LKY began from cultural and historical year Zero when Singapore was expelled from Malaysia. Only then did the economic miracle begin.
Would the British, many of whom could not accommodate an ethnic Indian PM of sixth generation British birth, accept that they have lost their title to their lands in that way?
I disagree with this analysis. The Chinese were already a majority in Singapore by the turn of the 20C. LKY's policy was to subsume ethnic rivalries into a common Singaporean nationalism/patriotism, which is why Singapore is an English-speaking country today, with language being a binding agent. And Singaporean "culture" is very Confucian and Overseas Chinese.
This would be somewhat akin to the somewhat sterile debate over English vs British, and in fact was to a great extent how Britain functioned after 1707, Great Britain, not England and Scotland.
And, again, just because one aspect of the Singapore story doesn't fit one's priors, does not mean that we cannot learn from the many others that do overlap.
My frame of reference was that of Singapore within the Federation of Malaysia.
LKY’s entire gambit with Federation was to argue that the Malays were no more the indigenous people of Malaya than anyone else.
It is worth bearing in mind how provocative that idea would sound to us in Britain. If a politician from a minority community began aggressively redefining what it meant to be ‘British’ and saying that the erstwhile indigenes would no longer be recognised as having a normative cultural or customary position.
We have seen it over three or four generations in Britain and it still a source of passionate disagreement. LKY was trying to do it in one. Less than a decade after Malay independence from Britain. A colonial system in which the Chinese had essentially been the preferred race.
And remember LKY actually spoke Malay. That was very unusual for a Singaporean Chinese at the time. He was an ostentatious moderate. A large proportion of the Straits Chinese community had ill concealed contempt for the ‘lazy Malays’.
That is the context we need to bear in mind, I think, when framing what LKY was proposing.
What most people miss about Singapore is its fragility - it really is an insignificant little sweaty spot of land, turned into what can be called the world's most successful country (by some measures at least). If China/UK/Italy screw things up for a few generations of bad leadership, they'll continue in some way. If Sg screws it up for a few years in a row, it is in mortal danger of disappearing off the map. LKY turned that terrifying fact into a philosophy.
Thanks Ed for another good post. If you're at a loose end during your time off Substack, you could do worse than pick up my book on Sg, 'Singapore Singapura: from miracle to complacency'. Either way, have a good couple of months.
As Ed said, it occupies an important place on the world’s sea lanes, and has a large harbour. It is also well positioned as a hub in the key “Indo-Pacific Region”. It won’t disappear off the map.
As a geographical location, even a physical, functioning place full of economic and social life - I agree, you're probably right. But as a fully independent and sovereign state? Yes, absolutely. I used to stay up late in my old house on the Watten Estate debating this with friends - amateur and professional country watchers. The consensus was that the ultimate fate if they screw up their government was most likely to be a reabsorption into Malaysia. East and Southeast Asia are now different places, and there are other options that seem possible that don't involve full sovereignty. Either way, Sg is a miracle, and the longer it is aware of this the longer that miracle can continue. I am extremely fond of it, and wish it all the best.
Understood. Though more broadly, other larger nations can also effectively disappear. Ireland - does that really exist? It lacks its own currency, it has no real control over who comes in, most laws are made elsewhere (and quite a lot of it is a legacy of British rule or incorporation, like the language and the older buildings in Dublin). Even the British Empire disappeared in a just a few years between 1945 and 1948, along with British control of the North Atlantic Ocean.
Absolutely. But this is also where it gets far more complicated than my original slightly glib point! Ireland will not cease to exist even if the make-up of the state changed, just as it didn't cease to exist after being incorporated into the British Empire. Italy as a state can feel quite artificial, but there is something resolute about the idea of Italy and Italians, even if some would prefer to be in Lombardy or Tuscany or whatever than the edifice called Italy. Singapore isn't like that - I'd argue that it's beyond artificial, and really a confection. The last century or so has certainly solidified the idea of Singapore, but how long would that last if the govt lost its performance legitimacy? It's been painstakingly assembled like a giant game of SimCity with a political aspect, and I still see it as deeply fragile. Look at the challenges: government performance, China's rise, a change in trade patterns, military/security confrontations, a global shift to low-carbon energy, or something that sets off ethnic tensions in Sg itself. Interesting. And the idea that nation states are set in stone is a left-over from the post-war settlement.
A fascinating start, on a subject which is close to my heart. Really looking forward to the rest.
It is worth pointing out that the origin of Singapore, both under Raffles and under LKY is viewed somewhat differently from the other end of The Causeway.
Temasek, as Singapore was once known, plays a key part in the ‘Malay Annals’ which is the Malay ancestral chronicle.
It was the birthplace of the Johore Sultanate and Raffles acquired it only under lease. It was only later appropriated in somewhat dubious circumstances by the Crown. So the idea, as widely put about by LKY and his Western admirers that the history of Singapore began with Raffles, Chinese merchants and Free Trade is highly contentious in Malaysia - to say the least!
Equally, for all his bluster about merit, openness, and Free Trade Lee Kwan Yew knew very well how to play the ‘racial’ racket to his advantage when he wanted to. He was a very sly old dog.
His ‘Malaysian Malaysia’ campaign of the mid 60s was not dissimilar the Melenchon’s current ‘creolisation’ movement in France. And equally obnoxious to the erstwhile ethnicity-in- posession. It cunningly leveraged a pretence of dispassionate post-racial civic identity onto what was really a front for a powerful ethnic Chinese lobby.
The reality at the time of the expulsion of Singapore was that the insular and clannish Chinese minority, long favoured by the British, would have totally dominated a reconstituted ‘civic’ Malay Union - and Lee knew it. He was asking the Malays to unilaterally put away their ancestral and customary privileges and safeguards - including the power of the Sultans and the ancient title of ‘Bumiputra’ which recognised them as ‘sons and stewards of the land’ while on the other hand he courted and cultivated the institutions of Chinese solidarity in the peninsula - the Tycoons, the Huay Kuans, the Dong Jiao Zong and even, at arms length, the Secret Societies.
From the Malay perspective, LKY’s inducements to the Malay nation to march forwards together into a post-historical, multi-racial civic nationalist republic was a case of the fox asking the chicken round to dinner.
Indeed, this suspicion seems to be borne out by the subsequent history. Singapore immigration policy still rigidly enforces a strict preponderance of ethnic Chinese in the Republic. The ethnic balance of 1965 is effectively frozen and enshrined in law. 75% Chinese forever. That is not the profile or workings of ‘civic’ nationalist meritocratic constitution. It is a latent Straits Chinese ethnostate. The Straits Chinese control the economy, the society, the culture and the story of the place and their children inevitably rise to the highest offices and richest sinecures and this is sold to the world as ‘meritocracy’ in action.
He never really wanted a full civic union - in my opinion - what he wanted was a sort of Malayan Common Market. A loose federation whereby Singapore would be entirely self governing while retaining privileged access to and oligarchic control of the Malaysian economy.
That was his gamble and his inducement to the ancient Malay nation. And they refused it.
I believe that is the true context of the famous ‘tears’. A gambler whose bluff was called.
A little like many in 1973, gulled by Heath et al that our constitutional independence would not be compromised by entry into the EEC.
But interesting context. We do, indeed view that part of the world from a Singaporean perspective, and I must confess being partial to overseas Chinese, having lived and worked in Hong Kong and visited Sing many times. Malaysia has, indeed, done great things, mostly by emulating Singaporean economic policy, but it is also a very corrupt country where it's one party state has benefited the rulers more than the ruled. Singapore, somewhat less.
The Straits Chinese are among the most dynamic, intelligent, impressive, decent, industrious people in the world. They are also intensely clannish, business-minded, competitive, striving and hard-nosed.
The Malay leadership in knew this in 1965. Their rejection of Singapore was very wise but also an enormous back-handed compliment to the Peranakan and Straits Chinese community.
Indeed Mahatir later explicitly framed it in this way in his essay ‘The Malay Dilemma’. He plainly said the Malays would have been out-competed by the Chinese and dispossessed in their own land if they had adopted a racially blind, meritocratic or laissez faire system.
The Malays may not have achieved Singaporean levels of public growth and wealth - or indeed public probity - but they have undoubtedly kept their own way of life and their own ownership of the land of their fathers in spite of all the headwinds and temptations of globalism and international finance.
As much as we can learn from Singapore we should remember that in the paradigm-as-a-parable under discussion the position of the British in Britain is analogous to that of the Malays in Malaya - not the Straits Chinese.
Part of this is the old story: multi-ethnic federations tend to break up. They usually stay together for security reasons, like Switzerland. I would note that security was still provided: the UK would not have tolerated any attempt to seize the place. Suppose China had landed, and declared the place a Chinese city?
But with that assurance, Singapore was able to go it alone, a great example of how political union is not needed for economic prosperity.
Minor point: UK is far richer. What Singapore has is about double the per capita income of the UK.
"A word that Lee uses a great deal is ‘soft’. In one broadcast he declared that: ‘If we were a soft society then we would already have perished. A soft people will vote for those who promised a soft way out, when in truth there is none. There is nothing Singapore gets for free, even our water we pay for… There will be a throbbing and humming industrial, commercial and communication centre long after the British have gone.’"
There is so much to learn from the Singapore story, and LKY's own political and cultural odyssey. He truly is the father of his country and an exemplar of the "great man theory" of history. I could never understand the leftist cringe away from the idea of a post-Brexit Britain being a Singapore-on-Thames. If only! I understand the PAP has a semi-authoritarian grip on the state's parliament and government, and that obviously wouldn't conform to Britain's history of liberty and freedoms. But the argument is to say that because of this, then nothing at all is comparable and ameliorable by the Singapore example. Public housing, public health service, public transport are all infinitely better run than here. As a free trade entrepot and open capital market, there is much we could emulate. Being self-reliant while embracing those areas of globalism that work for us seems to be a very attractive alternative to the hollowed out, impotent beggar state we are currently.
Years ago, I remember reading this evocative article about the hugely charismatic Egyptian leader Gamal Abdel Nasser, wondering what might have happened had Nasser followed the Lee Kuan Yew path instead of pursuing his revolutionary and socialist policies!
The face of the Middle East might have been, at least partly, very different. Egypt had the potential, the institutions, and the history—but so much of that potential was squandered!
Great comment. I have thought similar things about other places. It shows the importance of civic leadership.
Thanks Chris, that article was published in Arabic press! I always say that the Middle East can serve as a mirror to Europe’s future!
So right. Many places like that in the world. Think how Argentina crippled itself with Peronism.
Unfortunately, there does not seem to be the ability to understand the contribution of Western civilization in Arab countries (perhaps one can somewhat understand their prejudice) where Sinapore, Taiwan, Korea and even Japan have been able to do so, with much greater success, prosperity and maybe even happiness for those nations' people than much of the post-colonial world.
Egypt should be an economic powerhouse: it is, and appears always to have been, a basket case. And that has nothing to do with colonialism, where Lord Cromer's (and others) decades long interest in modernization of Egyptian administration, industry and agriculture was buried in the sands like the Sphinx.
Sultan Qaboos' Oman may be a better analogy for a medium-sized country in the Middle East rather than a city-state.
https://nationalinterest.org/feature/nobody-knows-wholl-be-charge-after-omans-founding-father-17195
I visited Singapore in 1984 as a young naval officer. Already then it was very clean and orderly, unlike other Asisan cities I had visited. Crime was essentially non-existent and we were told that this was not the place to get too rowdy or get in trouble because it wasn't tolerated. You can get an idea of how safe a city is by noticing groups of school girls walking alone after dark. The food was fabulous and relatively cheap due to the strong dollar in those days. I have always thought of Singapore fondly and glad for their success.
Hong Kong, when I was there (1994-2001, 2008-2011) was similar, though its inevitable Sinicization after 1997 (with tragic results since 2019) has made it a different and worse city - for all.
Coincidentally, I read this immediately after reading a review of the documentary movie “Empire of Dust” (the source of the “it’s all so tiresome” meme), in which the reviewer reflects that the Congo (et al.) took almost entirely the opposite approach to the great Singaporean.
Of course the Congolese were in a difficult situation, but still…
https://yuribezmenov.substack.com/p/empire-of-dust-ccp-congoits-all-so-tiresome-meme
that does sound interesting. Found on YouTube!
The break up of the Federation of Malay States is also my favourite response to that old dimwitted Scottish nationalist argument "Which country has not wanted to become independent?"
That the easy answer became such a success against its will, against the odds and with a firm grasp of economic reality adds to the humour.
Against its will? Perhaps against its best laid plans but I don’t think LKY or any of the leaders of the Singaporean faction wanted to be a unified part of the Federation of Malaya as constituted in 1965.
They negotiated fulsome and specific legal safeguards for near complete legal autonomy before they ventured to join in 1963. They had been a separate Crown Colony up to that point and never previously a part of the Malayan Federation or the Union or States that had preceded it.
Then they set about trying to undermine the privileged constitutional status and customary position of the Malays. Only then were they ejected.
In many ways it was a failed ‘hostile take over’ by an annexed exclave rather than an expulsion of a constituent state.
There is a lot of fine detail that gets missed when people set about allegorising the Singaporean miracle.
"Then they set about trying to undermine the privileged constitutional status and customary position of the Malays. Only then were they ejected." Any why wouldn't they? Bumiputra policy was racial preference in naked form.
Well, yes, and the Malays might say - so what?
Everyone in that part of the world thinks in what we would call ‘racial’ terms. Britain explicitly did until decolonisation. And then more or less implicitly thereafter. Until the last 15 years or so.
Malays consider themselves the indigenous people of the Malay peninsula and therefore feel entitled to the stewardship of the land and its resources.
Agreed. The Bumis were their own worst enemy.
How so? It strikes me that they have, for the most part, maintained their traditional and customary way of life with a state that is modernising and developing well on the terms they have laid down to best suit their own people.
They have had the best of globalism without many of the drawbacks.
"Lee would have gone on to great things in any case, but he happened to come of age in a notably turbulent period. If worldviews are indeed shaped by the events of an individual’s twentieth year, for the budding young law student it was the fall of Singapore in February 1942, the British Empire’s greatest defeat and humiliation. Lee noted at the time that, whatever happened next, this was the end of European rule."
I believe it was Napoleon Bonaparte who stated that if you want to understand a man, look at what was happening in the world when he was twenty.
The fall of not just Singapore but the whole of Malaya as it then was in 1941-42 is fascinating. The surprise attack began slightly before Pearl Harbour - yes, you read that right - but because of the International Date Line, history usually claims otherwise. The Vichy French helped the Japanese, as did the Thais (a bit), and the Japanese modelled their tactics on the German Blitzkrieg successes of 1940 in France. The British (Empire) could have kept them at bay, but their top leadership was so inept that it became, as Ed says, arguably one of the worst defeats in British military history.
My Malay sister in laws father saw the British soldiers retreating over the river Muar and blowing up the last bridges - ‘knock-kneed and coughing like hags’
He said he’d never seen a White Man unshaven before in his life.
Like LKY in the above piece, he said that, more even than the fall of Singapore itself, made him realise the Empire was over.
The Malaya garrison was absolutely tiny up to that point. It’s amazing how much of the Empire in the East Indies was effectively run in bluster and goodwill.
I can believe it. My Chinese-Singaporean friend says her father was in Singapore during the occupation and not surprisingly absolutely hated the Japanese from that point on!
The military debacle essentially rested on a completely daft premise IMO: the British Empire troops, many of them Indian, would invade southern Thailand when they were sure the Japanese were about to land there themselves, but they needed ideally about three days notice to get into position - which the Japanese didn’t give them, the bounders! There is also the naval aspect, with two RN battleships sunk from the air with minimal losses on the Japanese side…
"Yet the end of empire is always a precarious times for minorities, especially merchant peoples, and a majority Chinese city surrounded by majority Malay regions found itself very vulnerable, both from outside and within. As he put it: ‘We inherited the island without its hinterland, a heart without a body.’"
Hence the need for a "liberal case for empire" as you would say:
https://unherd.com/2020/10/the-progressive-case-for-empire/
"The great-grandson of Hakka-speaking immigrants, Lee came from the somewhat Anglicised Straits Chinese elite. Often British in their mindset, Lee describes himself as ‘the last Victorian’ and this worldview would shape Singapore’s history. "
One wonders if Prime Minister Ian Smith of Rhodesia might dispute that title.
1. Can a British Lee Kuan Yew rise from the ashes?
2. Can he confront the nation with hard truths?
3. Can he deal firmly but objectively with the prevailing narratives of the last five decades?
4. Can he tell the new hard right that British Muslims are not necessarily the enemy, while also telling British Muslims that necessary adjustments must be made?
5. Can he be a little patriarchal and tell white British women to end their addiction to OnlyFans and what have you?
6. Can he focus on excellent governance and motivate both the population and the chattering classes to move beyond the never-ending and futile ideological wars?
7. Can he speak to people honestly, but humanely, about the meaning of belonging and identity?
No :-(
Two things I find depressing about British politics:
1. A (small) majority of voters are left-wing. The Conservative Party won elections in England the past because the left wing vote was split between two parties (Labour and the Liberal Democrats). But now the right-wing vote is split too. Also, younger people are more left-wing than older people. So I don't think the British public will ever take to anyone who confronts them with hard truths.
2. Both of our right-wing parties, the Conservatives and Reform, are ignoring the fact that Britain has huge debts and borrowing costs are high. They are both promising tax cuts and higher spending (for example, on defence), with no realistic plan to pay for the things they are promising. They are also both NIMBY parties who won't face up to the need to build things (houses, electricity pylons) on the green belt or in the bucolic countryside.
I hope so . . . Just as in 1979, there is a time for a great man, or great woman to save us from ourselves. But it is a matter of will and choice. Always.
A British Lee Kwan Yew’s first target would be the racial pride and historic exceptionalism of the indigenous people of Britain. That is the prologue to the Singapore story that is so poorly understood by his backers in Britain.
He would say to the English, as he said to the Malays in the ancient lands of their fathers - ‘you have no special right or place in this land over and above anyone else. Your history is abolished. Your title to normative culture in this place is revoked. Your expectation of special consideration in the disposal of its destiny is refused. Your claim to inherited oversight and stewardship of this land is forthwith denied.’
LKY began from cultural and historical year Zero when Singapore was expelled from Malaysia. Only then did the economic miracle begin.
Would the British, many of whom could not accommodate an ethnic Indian PM of sixth generation British birth, accept that they have lost their title to their lands in that way?
I disagree with this analysis. The Chinese were already a majority in Singapore by the turn of the 20C. LKY's policy was to subsume ethnic rivalries into a common Singaporean nationalism/patriotism, which is why Singapore is an English-speaking country today, with language being a binding agent. And Singaporean "culture" is very Confucian and Overseas Chinese.
This would be somewhat akin to the somewhat sterile debate over English vs British, and in fact was to a great extent how Britain functioned after 1707, Great Britain, not England and Scotland.
And, again, just because one aspect of the Singapore story doesn't fit one's priors, does not mean that we cannot learn from the many others that do overlap.
My frame of reference was that of Singapore within the Federation of Malaysia.
LKY’s entire gambit with Federation was to argue that the Malays were no more the indigenous people of Malaya than anyone else.
It is worth bearing in mind how provocative that idea would sound to us in Britain. If a politician from a minority community began aggressively redefining what it meant to be ‘British’ and saying that the erstwhile indigenes would no longer be recognised as having a normative cultural or customary position.
We have seen it over three or four generations in Britain and it still a source of passionate disagreement. LKY was trying to do it in one. Less than a decade after Malay independence from Britain. A colonial system in which the Chinese had essentially been the preferred race.
And remember LKY actually spoke Malay. That was very unusual for a Singaporean Chinese at the time. He was an ostentatious moderate. A large proportion of the Straits Chinese community had ill concealed contempt for the ‘lazy Malays’.
That is the context we need to bear in mind, I think, when framing what LKY was proposing.
What most people miss about Singapore is its fragility - it really is an insignificant little sweaty spot of land, turned into what can be called the world's most successful country (by some measures at least). If China/UK/Italy screw things up for a few generations of bad leadership, they'll continue in some way. If Sg screws it up for a few years in a row, it is in mortal danger of disappearing off the map. LKY turned that terrifying fact into a philosophy.
Thanks Ed for another good post. If you're at a loose end during your time off Substack, you could do worse than pick up my book on Sg, 'Singapore Singapura: from miracle to complacency'. Either way, have a good couple of months.
Thank you. I will look that up!
As Ed said, it occupies an important place on the world’s sea lanes, and has a large harbour. It is also well positioned as a hub in the key “Indo-Pacific Region”. It won’t disappear off the map.
As a geographical location, even a physical, functioning place full of economic and social life - I agree, you're probably right. But as a fully independent and sovereign state? Yes, absolutely. I used to stay up late in my old house on the Watten Estate debating this with friends - amateur and professional country watchers. The consensus was that the ultimate fate if they screw up their government was most likely to be a reabsorption into Malaysia. East and Southeast Asia are now different places, and there are other options that seem possible that don't involve full sovereignty. Either way, Sg is a miracle, and the longer it is aware of this the longer that miracle can continue. I am extremely fond of it, and wish it all the best.
Understood. Though more broadly, other larger nations can also effectively disappear. Ireland - does that really exist? It lacks its own currency, it has no real control over who comes in, most laws are made elsewhere (and quite a lot of it is a legacy of British rule or incorporation, like the language and the older buildings in Dublin). Even the British Empire disappeared in a just a few years between 1945 and 1948, along with British control of the North Atlantic Ocean.
Absolutely. But this is also where it gets far more complicated than my original slightly glib point! Ireland will not cease to exist even if the make-up of the state changed, just as it didn't cease to exist after being incorporated into the British Empire. Italy as a state can feel quite artificial, but there is something resolute about the idea of Italy and Italians, even if some would prefer to be in Lombardy or Tuscany or whatever than the edifice called Italy. Singapore isn't like that - I'd argue that it's beyond artificial, and really a confection. The last century or so has certainly solidified the idea of Singapore, but how long would that last if the govt lost its performance legitimacy? It's been painstakingly assembled like a giant game of SimCity with a political aspect, and I still see it as deeply fragile. Look at the challenges: government performance, China's rise, a change in trade patterns, military/security confrontations, a global shift to low-carbon energy, or something that sets off ethnic tensions in Sg itself. Interesting. And the idea that nation states are set in stone is a left-over from the post-war settlement.
A fascinating start, on a subject which is close to my heart. Really looking forward to the rest.
It is worth pointing out that the origin of Singapore, both under Raffles and under LKY is viewed somewhat differently from the other end of The Causeway.
Temasek, as Singapore was once known, plays a key part in the ‘Malay Annals’ which is the Malay ancestral chronicle.
It was the birthplace of the Johore Sultanate and Raffles acquired it only under lease. It was only later appropriated in somewhat dubious circumstances by the Crown. So the idea, as widely put about by LKY and his Western admirers that the history of Singapore began with Raffles, Chinese merchants and Free Trade is highly contentious in Malaysia - to say the least!
Equally, for all his bluster about merit, openness, and Free Trade Lee Kwan Yew knew very well how to play the ‘racial’ racket to his advantage when he wanted to. He was a very sly old dog.
His ‘Malaysian Malaysia’ campaign of the mid 60s was not dissimilar the Melenchon’s current ‘creolisation’ movement in France. And equally obnoxious to the erstwhile ethnicity-in- posession. It cunningly leveraged a pretence of dispassionate post-racial civic identity onto what was really a front for a powerful ethnic Chinese lobby.
The reality at the time of the expulsion of Singapore was that the insular and clannish Chinese minority, long favoured by the British, would have totally dominated a reconstituted ‘civic’ Malay Union - and Lee knew it. He was asking the Malays to unilaterally put away their ancestral and customary privileges and safeguards - including the power of the Sultans and the ancient title of ‘Bumiputra’ which recognised them as ‘sons and stewards of the land’ while on the other hand he courted and cultivated the institutions of Chinese solidarity in the peninsula - the Tycoons, the Huay Kuans, the Dong Jiao Zong and even, at arms length, the Secret Societies.
From the Malay perspective, LKY’s inducements to the Malay nation to march forwards together into a post-historical, multi-racial civic nationalist republic was a case of the fox asking the chicken round to dinner.
Indeed, this suspicion seems to be borne out by the subsequent history. Singapore immigration policy still rigidly enforces a strict preponderance of ethnic Chinese in the Republic. The ethnic balance of 1965 is effectively frozen and enshrined in law. 75% Chinese forever. That is not the profile or workings of ‘civic’ nationalist meritocratic constitution. It is a latent Straits Chinese ethnostate. The Straits Chinese control the economy, the society, the culture and the story of the place and their children inevitably rise to the highest offices and richest sinecures and this is sold to the world as ‘meritocracy’ in action.
He never really wanted a full civic union - in my opinion - what he wanted was a sort of Malayan Common Market. A loose federation whereby Singapore would be entirely self governing while retaining privileged access to and oligarchic control of the Malaysian economy.
That was his gamble and his inducement to the ancient Malay nation. And they refused it.
I believe that is the true context of the famous ‘tears’. A gambler whose bluff was called.
A little like many in 1973, gulled by Heath et al that our constitutional independence would not be compromised by entry into the EEC.
But interesting context. We do, indeed view that part of the world from a Singaporean perspective, and I must confess being partial to overseas Chinese, having lived and worked in Hong Kong and visited Sing many times. Malaysia has, indeed, done great things, mostly by emulating Singaporean economic policy, but it is also a very corrupt country where it's one party state has benefited the rulers more than the ruled. Singapore, somewhat less.
The Straits Chinese are among the most dynamic, intelligent, impressive, decent, industrious people in the world. They are also intensely clannish, business-minded, competitive, striving and hard-nosed.
The Malay leadership in knew this in 1965. Their rejection of Singapore was very wise but also an enormous back-handed compliment to the Peranakan and Straits Chinese community.
Indeed Mahatir later explicitly framed it in this way in his essay ‘The Malay Dilemma’. He plainly said the Malays would have been out-competed by the Chinese and dispossessed in their own land if they had adopted a racially blind, meritocratic or laissez faire system.
The Malays may not have achieved Singaporean levels of public growth and wealth - or indeed public probity - but they have undoubtedly kept their own way of life and their own ownership of the land of their fathers in spite of all the headwinds and temptations of globalism and international finance.
As much as we can learn from Singapore we should remember that in the paradigm-as-a-parable under discussion the position of the British in Britain is analogous to that of the Malays in Malaya - not the Straits Chinese.
‘We’ are the Bumpitra, not the Peranakan.
Part of this is the old story: multi-ethnic federations tend to break up. They usually stay together for security reasons, like Switzerland. I would note that security was still provided: the UK would not have tolerated any attempt to seize the place. Suppose China had landed, and declared the place a Chinese city?
But with that assurance, Singapore was able to go it alone, a great example of how political union is not needed for economic prosperity.
Minor point: UK is far richer. What Singapore has is about double the per capita income of the UK.
Fascinating. He sounds like such a nice and impressive man.
"A word that Lee uses a great deal is ‘soft’. In one broadcast he declared that: ‘If we were a soft society then we would already have perished. A soft people will vote for those who promised a soft way out, when in truth there is none. There is nothing Singapore gets for free, even our water we pay for… There will be a throbbing and humming industrial, commercial and communication centre long after the British have gone.’"
There is so much to learn from the Singapore story, and LKY's own political and cultural odyssey. He truly is the father of his country and an exemplar of the "great man theory" of history. I could never understand the leftist cringe away from the idea of a post-Brexit Britain being a Singapore-on-Thames. If only! I understand the PAP has a semi-authoritarian grip on the state's parliament and government, and that obviously wouldn't conform to Britain's history of liberty and freedoms. But the argument is to say that because of this, then nothing at all is comparable and ameliorable by the Singapore example. Public housing, public health service, public transport are all infinitely better run than here. As a free trade entrepot and open capital market, there is much we could emulate. Being self-reliant while embracing those areas of globalism that work for us seems to be a very attractive alternative to the hollowed out, impotent beggar state we are currently.
Thanks for this. It prompted me to purchase both volumes of Lee's autobiography. Can't wait till they arrive.