Great article Ed, this sort of thing is why I read you and send you money. Really looking forward to your The West's Cultural Revolution is Over book as this is an intensely fascinating phenomenon and you're the only person I can think of who has precisely delineated what is going on as you have.

As far as the First Amendment goes, speaking as an American, I am insanely grateful that we have it. Now, the people in charge of the Blue Tribe have made it so that your entire life can be ruined by saying or thinking the wrong thing (this business where they get people frozen out of the financial system is especially scary), but you can't be imprisoned for it.

At least, not yet. I fully expect for a left-leaning Supreme court to, some time in the not too distant future, rule that "hate speech" is not protected by the First Amendment... and "hate speech" can be ANYTHING. Won't happen anytime soon because of the right tilt of the current court, but I fully expect this to occur after 2030 or so at some point.

Also if you're interested here's a fun disquisition about what's going on with America's blue tribe. Would like to hear what you think of this. Half of me thinks it's genius and the other half thinks it's unhinged: https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/revenge-of-the-yankees

Expand full comment

Poor Socrates. Then again, he was indisputably annoying and did corrupt the youth by encouraging them to question the wisdom of their elders.

Even here in the United States, the First Amendment is in hot water for the first time in American history because it's apparently now a product of white supremacy and institutional racism, ya know. That we ever got to this point, and so suddenly, is certainly a testament to the culture wars and the explosive growth in the powers of the woke progressives. But at least we still have the First Amendment and the Constitution is devilishly tricky to change. But even so, people are noting a creeping double standard in prosecution and application of laws and policies.

Expand full comment

I misread this headline as 'Why Britain needs a 2nd amendment' and thought you'd gone off the deep end, Ed :p

Expand full comment

If blasphemy laws cover all beliefs, it means all beliefs are sacred. if all beliefs are sacred, then none are technically. In actuality, the secular elites who stand 'above ideology' treat their own viewpoints as very jolly sacred thank you very much, and don't you forget it, sinner.

That said, I am not in favour of the First Amendment. I know this may not be a popular opinion here, hopefully it won't constitute blasphemy. I don't like freedom of speech. Nobody does really. No, NOBODY. Every society has blasphemy laws, formally or informally - even (especially) the USA. I just want our blasphemy laws to be crystal-clear, with consistent sentencing, and if at all possible, directed against the enemies of Christ, as defined by me. No problem, right?

But seriously, the danger with modern day blasphemy laws is that unlike laws regulating what you can say about the Holy Trinity or the whether you think transubstantiation is holy dogma or papist folly, modern day dogmas demand you assent to statements about THIS world, about reality as dealt with on a daily basis. You must affirm, instead of arcane doctrine about the afterlife or hypostatic unions, none of which can be proven in the everyday sense of the term, you must assent to rather strange ideas about men and women, ideas that very few people truly believe. You must assent to weird dogmas about race and discrimination, in violation of your own eyes and ears, you must assent that it would be best if you and your people were to simply go extinct and be replaced by others. And that's just the start.

Expand full comment

The inconsistency of hate speech prosecutions (or social platform cancellations) reminds me of stochastic terrorist acts. They serve to make many more people afraid than really need to be and so implement a shadowy type of control over society.

Expand full comment

As an American, I can tell you that we have a First Amendment for the government, but not for private businesses or organizations! That’s where the pressure comes from in America.

Expand full comment

I simply can't believe women are being jailed for insisting that men aren't women in the UK. Like the Rotherham sex scandal it's one of those things you read about on social media, assume it's some crazy rambling nonsense, and then you find out it's completely true and nothing seems quite right after...

And this is with your Conservatives in power for over a freaking decade? Seriously? They do realize the Blue Tribe here is never going to like or approve of them, right? (Note the US Blue Tribe will never approve of any (white) British as being anything but a pathetic and castrated bitch apologizing for your ancestors. Please don't feed them). But for real, the whole trans thing has taken off while the Conservatives have been in control. And in that time the UK has become one of the legal leaders in persecuting those who stand up to this nonsense! All completely under Conservative leadership.


ps I do not write this to mock. I live about an hour outside LA and trust me it breaks my heart when people treat the worst fucking ideas ever made here, coming straight from the mouths of the most utterly vile, as the new gospel. Try Scientology instead, please.

Expand full comment